Well, I must say I was pretty impressed by this movie. I liked the style they chose for the film, having some scenes from the "Present" (1919) which are black and white, and some scenes from the "Past" (1870) which are full color and very rich color at that. The acting was very well done, though I admittedly thought Gerard Butler could have done better singing. The music was fantastic, catchy, and very memorable. The overall effect was very wowing to me.
I know some will disagree, but hey, this is my review not yours.

A